Between $400,000 - $500,000 Penfield NY Real Estate, Homes, Condos for Sale

Welcome home to this beautifully maintained Cape Cod in the heart of Penfield, where timeless charm meets thoughtful updates. This home has been lovingly maintained by the original owner. Step inside to a stunning living room with soaring cathedral ceilings and an abundance of natural light, creating a warm and inviting first impression. The spacious living room is centered around a cozy gas fireplace, making it the perfect place to gather. The beautifully renovated kitchen is sure to impress with granite countertops, a striking range hood, tile backsplash, and quality finishes throughout. Entertain with ease in the formal dining room, where a large bay window fills the space with natural light. The first-floor owner's suite offers the convenience of single-level living, featuring generous space, a walk-in closet, and an ensuite bath with a double vanity. First-floor laundry adds even more everyday convenience. Upstairs, you'll find two additional spacious bedrooms along with a beautifully remodeled full bathroom. The finished lower level provides valuable flexible living space, complemented by an oversized storage closet and a large unfinished area ideal for a workshop, hobby space, or additional storage. Outside, enjoy the private backyard surrounded by lush landscaping and relax on the spacious 2-level deck. A second patio at the front of the home offers another inviting spot to enjoy your morning coffee or unwind in the evening. Whole home generator is the cherry on top. Combining classic Cape Cod character with modern updates and an exceptional Penfield location, this is a home you won't want to miss. Delayed Showings/Negotiation. Showings begin 07/28/26 at 10am. Offers to be submitted on 08/03/26 by noon and good until 8pm.

22 Cobblestone Crossing, Penfield

$469,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1699228 MLS

Welcome home to this charming Colonial nestled on a large, private cul-de-sac lot in the heart of Penfield! Surrounded by mature trees and abundant wildlife, this exceptional property offers a peaceful retreat just minutes from shopping, dining, parks, and everyday conveniences. Inside, you'll find a spacious floor plan designed for comfortable living and effortless entertaining. The inviting living room, formal dining room, and beautifully updated kitchen make gathering easy. The kitchen features custom Brookhaven cabinetry with pull-out shelves, quartz countertops, double ovens, and abundant workspace. Right off the kitchen you'll find a STUNNING SUNROOM with a vaulted ceiling and two skylights that fill the space with natural light. Step outside to the new oversized composite deck, perfect for relaxing, dining, or entertaining while overlooking the private backyard. A BRAND NEW TEAR OFF ROOF along with the low-maintenance vinyl siding provide lasting value and peace of mind. Upstairs, you'll find four generously sized bedrooms, including a spacious primary suite with an updated ensuite featuring a granite-topped vanity, tiled shower, and walk-in closet. The partially finished basement offers flexible space for a home office, recreation room, gym, or playroom. A convenient first floor mud room/laundry room with new custom built-ins welcome you in from the 2+ car attached garage with smart access, abundant storage, and a separate overhead door providing convenient backyard access. This move-in-ready home combines quality craftsmanship, thoughtful updates, and an unbeatable private setting in one of Penfield's most desirable neighborhoods. You won't want to miss this one! Delayed Negotiations Mon July 27th at 12pm. Open House Sat 25th 12-2pm

36 Autumn Oak Circle, Penfield

$425,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1699465 MLS

Welcome home to this impeccably maintained split-level nestled in the highly sought-after Penfield School District! From the moment you arrive, you'll appreciate the pride of ownership and timeless charm found throughout this move-in ready home. Inside, you'll find beautiful original hardwood floors that add warmth and character, along with custom built-ins in the living and dining rooms that provide both style and functionality. The updated kitchen is a standout, featuring rich cherry hardwood cabinetry, granite countertops, a travertine tile backsplash, under-cabinet lighting, and ample workspace for everyday living and entertaining. The flexible floor plan offers the option of a first-floor bedroom, home office, or den to fit your lifestyle. An updated half bath, neutral paint colors throughout, and abundant storage make this home as practical as it is inviting. Step outside to relax in the screened-in porch overlooking the spacious backyard, complete with a storage shed and surrounded by extensive, lush landscaping that creates a peaceful outdoor retreat. Vinyl replacement windows provide added energy efficiency and low-maintenance living. This lovingly cared-for home offers the perfect combination of classic character, thoughtful updates, and a fantastic location close to parks, shopping, restaurants, and everything Penfield has to offer. Don't miss your opportunity to make this exceptional property your next home!Delayed showings until Tuesday 7/21/26 at 9 am. Delayed Negotiations until Tuesday 7/28/26 at 11 am.

68 Hillcrest Drive, Penfield

$449,900

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1699063 MLS

Welcome to this completely renovated, like-new-build 4 bed, 2 bath home with Webster Schools. Tastefully updated from top to bottom in 2023 with modern finishes and an open-concept layout perfect for everyday living or entertaining. The stunning kitchen features custom cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, a large island with quartz countertops and waterfall edges, plus a coffee bar. All new flooring, 2-panel doors with modern hardware, lighting, switches, and outlets throughout. The spacious primary suite offers vaulted ceilings, a large walk-in shower, and two custom walk-in closets with 2nd floor laundry! Tons of natural light throughout, complemented by custom window treatments that stay with the home. A 3-pane sliding glass door leads to the insulated sunroom with all new flooring and windows (2026), providing additional square footage not included in the total. Step outside to a maintenance-free composite deck (2026), and a large fully-fenced backyard. Low maintenance vinyl siding and mostly vinyl windows. Peace of mind with a new roof featuring architectural shingles, gutters, and soffits (2024), furnace (2022), hot water tank (2020), and well-maintained central AC. New insulated garage door (2025). Tucked away on a quiet neighborhood street with easy access to expressways, shops, and restaurants. Just minutes from Irondequoit Bay and Lake Ontario. This home has it all! Transparent pricing, with delayed negotiations on Tuesday 7/28/26 12:00p.

91 Kirkland Drive, Penfield

$499,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1692894 MLS

This 2,428 square foot, 4-bedroom, 2.5 bath contemporary colonial is located on a private drive a minute away from Midvale Country Club and just minutes from Fairport Village. A beautiful and unique setting. First floor primary. First floor laundry. Fabulous kitchen and primary bath updated in 2019. Paneled family room has a vaulted ceiling, overlook and wood burning fireplace, with a view to a big, shaded backyard and pond. Generous dining room. Large office with exterior entrance suitable for music teaching studio or professional services. Walk-out basement with wood burning stove. Hardwood floors in excellent condition. Includes all appliances. Per seller- no delayed negotiations and no escalation clauses.

15 Valewood Run, Penfield

$400,000

R1689804 MLS

Prime 3.78± acre development opportunity in the Town of Penfield! This unique parcel (Lot 23) offers conceptual approval for a 16,000 square foot building for a senior living community or elder care facility. The property is surrounded by established residential neighborhoods while maintaining a private, wooded setting that is well suited for residential care or senior housing use. Partial constructed retention pond has been started for drainage. Utilities are available at the street, offering added convenience for future development. Located in one of Monroe County's most desirable communities, this property provides easy access to shopping, medical facilities, restaurants, and major transportation routes. A rare opportunity for developers, investors, and operators seeking a well-positioned site with strong future potential.

1345 Shoecraft Road, Penfield

$499,900

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1679208 MLS

Completely transformed from top to bottom, this property offers a rare turnkey opportunity. Recent improvements include a complete tear-off roof, all new windows and doors, and extensive exterior upgrades. A newly poured sidewalk wraps around the building and extends to the front and rear parking areas, enhancing both access and curb appeal. The property features a newly paved 32-car parking lot, with a recorded easement through the Town of Penfield, allowing for convenient secondary exit access--an exceptional benefit for traffic flow and usability. The former garage has been fully renovated into functional interior space, currently utilized as the main cutting area, adding versatility to the layout. This is a prime opportunity for an owner-user or investor seeking a fully updated property with strong infrastructure and accessibility already in place. Current business renters are willing to continue leasing back by new owner.

1181 Bay Road, Penfield

$499,900

R1664583 MLS

Completely transformed from top to bottom, this property offers a rare turnkey opportunity. Recent improvements include a complete tear-off roof, all new windows and doors, and extensive exterior upgrades. A newly poured sidewalk wraps around the building and extends to the front and rear parking areas, enhancing both access and curb appeal. The property features a newly paved 32-car parking lot, with a recorded easement through the Town of Penfield, allowing for convenient secondary exit access--an exceptional benefit for traffic flow and usability. The former garage has been fully renovated into functional interior space, currently utilized as the main cutting area, adding versatility to the layout. This is a prime opportunity for an owner-user or investor seeking a fully updated property with strong infrastructure and accessibility already in place. Current business renters are willing to continue leasing back by new owner.

1181 Bay Road, Penfield

$414,900

R1659228 MLS

Discover the City View Professional Building, ideally situated on the border of Webster and Penfield, NY—perfect for your medical or professional office needs. This second-floor condo office was previously an OBGYN practice, the space is versatile and adaptable for any medical or professional office use. Key features include: Private elevator leading directly to a welcoming lobby/reception area Four private offices Seven exam rooms Two dedicated bathrooms Fully equipped lab and a convenient break room Don't miss this exceptional opportunity to establish your practice in a prime location. Motivated seller ready to make a deal. The seller is eager to sell quickly and is open to contributing toward renovations or updates, creating an excellent opportunity for buyers to customize the space to fit their needs. Don’t miss this exceptional opportunity to establish your practice in a prime, highly accessible location.

1630 Empire Boulevard, Penfield

Browse All Penfield NY Between $400K - $500K Properties for Sale

Between $400K - $500K Penfield Real Estate