Browse All Penfield NY Between $400K - $500K Properties for Sale

Beautifully transformed from top to bottom and truly move-in ready! Welcome to this stunning 4-bedroom Colonial offering over 2,100 SqFt of beautifully updated living space in a desirable Penfield neighborhood and situated on an almost .5 acre lot! From the moment you arrive, you'll appreciate the incredible curb appeal, featuring updated exterior siding and gutters, a new driveway, new front walkway and welcoming new front door! Step inside to discover a completely refreshed interior with fresh paint '26 gleaming hardwood floors, stylish new lighting and updated window treatments throughout! A gorgeous, modern kitchen featuring crisp white cabinetry, solid surface countertops, tile backsplash, stainless steel appliances including a wine fridge, newly added dishwasher, and beautiful butcher block island! The open-concept layout flows seamlessly into the formal dining and living spaces, creating the perfect setting for entertaining. Beautifully refinished hardwood floors continue into the inviting family room, complete with a cozy fireplace! A convenient first-floor laundry/mudroom and fully remodeled powder room complete the main level. Upstairs, the hardwoods flow throughout all four generously sized bedrooms, including a spacious primary suite with a stunning newly remodeled ensuite bathroom and walk-in shower! All three bathrooms have been thoughtfully updated, including a second full bath that was fully remodeled with new double sinks! But the real surprise awaits downstairs! An incredible space featuring a full rock-climbing wall, jungle gym, and dedicated play area offers endless possibilities for fun! Outside, enjoy the fully fenced backyard surrounding the spacious and private backyard! Extensive interior and exterior renovations. Beautifully updated and ready for its next chapter.

29 Alta Vista Drive, Penfield

$495,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1718918 MLS

Welcome home to 3 Hidden Meadow in Penfield - This beautiful colonial offers space, comfort, and room to enjoy every season! This spacious Penfield home offers four large bedrooms with new plush carpeting, two-and-a-half updated baths, and an updated eat-in kitchen featuring modern finishes. The first floor is designed for everyday living and entertaining, with a versatile room for an office, living room, family room, formal dining room, and convenient first-floor laundry. Gather with family and friends on the expansive rear deck, which overlooks a patio and huge backyard with plenty of room to play, garden, or simply relax. An attached two-car garage makes daily life easy, while the large basement offers abundant storage and additional possibilities. A wonderful home with the space and flexibility you've been looking for!

3 Hidden Mdw, Penfield

$463,900

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1718092 MLS

Tucked on a quiet cul-de-sac in a highly desirable Penfield neighborhood, 262 Hillary Lane offers comfortable living and thoughtful updates. Recent improvements include a new roof and gutters, new carpet throughout, a new water heater, new exterior gable trim, and fresh interior paint. A 1.2 kW solar and battery backup system includes two 300 Ah LiFePO4 batteries with approximately 5.8 kWh of usable storage. Six individually selectable circuits—for the refrigerator, furnace fan, sump pump, garage door opener, internet, and basement freezer—can receive backup power during an outage, while the system also helps reduce normal grid electricity use. From the front entry, continue directly to the kitchen, equipped with a new double oven and microwave. Just off the kitchen is a spacious family room currently wired for surround sound with cable and fiber optic internet access available. Directly off the family room is a screened-in back porch enhanced by new construction elements and aluminum screening. The private porch is ideal for entertaining or relaxing on summer evenings. The den features custom built-in shelving and a cozy wood-burning fireplace. The main level also includes dining and living rooms, plus a first-floor laundry room conveniently located near the attached two-car garage. Upstairs are four generously sized bedrooms, including a primary suite with a large closet and private bathroom. The full basement provides ample storage and flexible space to suit your needs. Located in the Penfield school district with close access to parks, shopping and community amenities, this home is move in ready and looking for the next owner’s personal touch.

262 Hillary Lane, Penfield

$419,900

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1716363 MLS

BACK ON THE MARKET WITH A PRICE IMPROVEMENT — AND EVEN MORE REASON TO MAKE THIS ONE YOURS. Where timeless style meets completely reimagined living, this beautifully updated Penfield home offers the space, versatility, and finish you’ve been waiting for. Featuring 4 bedrooms and 2.5 baths, this home has been thoughtfully transformed from top to bottom, creating a truly move-in-ready experience. From the new windows throughout to the 2021 furnace and hot water tank, the major updates have already been taken care of, allowing you to simply settle in and enjoy. The heart of the home is the stunning kitchen, designed to be as functional as it is beautiful. A gas range, gorgeous backsplash, abundant cabinetry, oversized center island, and dedicated space for a dining table create the perfect setting for everything from casual mornings to dinner parties with friends. Two separate living/family room spaces give you room to entertain, relax, work from home, or create distinct spaces for everyone to enjoy. The bedrooms offer generous proportions and large closets, while the fourth bedroom is currently styled as a sophisticated home office—showcasing just how versatile the space can be. Use it as a bedroom, office, playroom, nursery, kids’ retreat, hobby room, or whatever your lifestyle calls for. And then there’s the location. Set in the Penfield school district, you’re just moments from beautiful parks, golf courses, restaurants, shopping, and everyday conveniences—giving you the best of both neighborhood living and easy access to everything the area has to offer. Completely updated. Exceptionally versatile. Beautifully presented. And now offered with a price improvement. This isn't simply a home that has been updated—it’s a home that has been reimagined for the way you want to live. NO DELAYED NEGOTIATIONS, this home is priced to sell.

1747 Scribner Road, Penfield

$410,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1715126 MLS

Welcome to highly desirable Allen Creek Valley! This exceptional end-unit townhome offers the perfect blend of comfort, privacy, and convenience with 3 bedrooms and 2.5 baths. A standout feature is the first-floor primary bedroom suite, providing easy one-level living while still offering additional bedrooms and living space upstairs. The inviting eat-in kitchen features beautiful granite countertops, included appliances, and a brand-new refrigerator (2026). The spacious great room is designed for comfortable living and entertaining, highlighted by a dramatic cathedral ceiling and cozy gas fireplace. A first-floor laundry adds to the convenience, with the washer and dryer replaced in 2024. Enjoy the outdoors from the freshly painted rear deck, complete with a retractable awning and a peaceful, private-feeling setting overlooking beautifully landscaped grounds. The awning motor was replaced in 2024, making this an ideal spot for relaxing or entertaining. Additional updates include a new furnace and air conditioner in 2022. A two-car garage provides ample parking and storage. And for today’s connected lifestyle, Allen Creek Valley offers access to popular Greenlight internet service. The HOA provides an impressive array of amenities and services, including tennis and pickleball courts, snow plowing, lawn mowing, water and sewer, trash removal, and exterior building maintenance. With its sought-after end-unit location, first-floor primary suite, wonderful community amenities, and numerous updates, this townhome is a wonderful opportunity in Allen Creek Valley! OPEN HOUSE OCT 25 NOON-1:30PM.

5 Hill Creek Road, Penfield

1742 Fairport Nine Mile Point Road, Penfield

$475,000

R1713691 MLS

MIXED USE DISTRICE.ZONE B. (RESIDENTIAL WITH NON-RESIDENTIAL. Currently used as residence with in-law. Permitted 2,3,4 Family, townhouse, limited offices, massage, art gallery, medical, offices, insurance, hair stylist. There is a Shop in the back for 2+ cars, with compressor, wood heat and water available, 100 amp service. Attached 2+ car garage with 220electric panel. Shockingly Country in the back 2 acres, and as per the town the property in the rear of this property will stay country. Property is in impeccable condition from top to bottom, new roof, gutter with leaf guard, new comfort windows, too many upgrades to list. There are solar panels on the South side. In-law apartment in lower level is well done. Please check with the town zoning for specific use allowed. Delayed showings to 9/10/26. Delayed negotiations to September 19th at 4pm.

1742 Fairport Nine Mile Point Road, Penfield

$424,900

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1696596 MLS

A TRULY RARE OPPORTUNITY TO OWN A PIECE OF HISTORY IN THE HEART OF PENFIELD! A CHARMING CIRCA-1820 FARMHOUSE, AND SEVERAL OUTBUILDINGS, ALL SET ON A BEAUTIFULLY MAINTAINED PARCEL. HORSES ARE PERMITTED, AND THE FORMER BARN INCLUDES TWO HORSE STALLS, OFFERING ADDITIONAL VERSATILITY FOR EQUESTRIAN ENTHUSIASTS. IDEALLY SITUATED, PROVIDING A PRIVATE, PEACEFUL SETTING, THIS REMARKABLE PROPERTY HAS BEEN LOVINGLY ENJOYED FOR MORE THAN 50 YEARS. NUMEROUS IMPROVEMENTS AND UPDATES HAVE BEEN MADE THROUGHOUT THE YEARS. THE PROPERTY AND ALL STRUCTURES WILL CONVEY IN "AS-IS" CONDITION. LISTING AGENT MUST BE PRESENT FOR ALL SHOWINGS. PLEASE ALLOW AMPLE TIME WHEN SCHEDULING YOUR APPOINTMENT, AS THIS IS A TRULY SPECIAL PROPERTY WITH MUCH TO EXPLORE AND APPRECIATE.

1651 Harris Road, Penfield

Start Your Search

Between $400K - $500K Penfield Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for between $400k - $500k properties available in Penfield and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Browse All Penfield NY Between $400K - $500K Properties for Sale

Between $400K - $500K Penfield Real Estate

How much is your home worth?

How much is your home worth?