Browse All Ontario NY Historical Properties for Sale

Incredible opportunity to own a home rich in history & timeless character, thoughtfully updated w/ the modern conveniences of today. Tucked back on nearly 5 private acres, this exceptional property offers the perfect balance of open green space & mature woods. Wander through the beautifully established gardens or embrace a more self-sufficient lifestyle w/ the chicken coop. Whether you're listening to the birds, gardening or enjoying an evening around a fire, the outdoor spaces offer endless opportunities to relax & unwind. The detached 2-car garage provides ample room for vehicles & storage, while the 600 sq ft of finished, heated space above is an incredible bonus. Complete w/ a bar, it's the perfect spot for entertaining, a home office, or rec room. From the moment you arrive, you'll appreciate the inviting curb appeal & welcoming covered front porch that reflects the home's historic charm. A 2nd oversized covered porch features composite decking & plenty of space for outdoor lounging while overlooking the picturesque backyard & gardens. Inside, beautifully maintained hardwood floors & original character create an immediate sense of warmth. Double French doors lead into the living room, where a large window frames peaceful backyard. The kitchen blends function & style w/ abundant cabinetry, expansive countertop space, a gas cooktop, double ovens, & a large peninsula w/ seating. The formal dining room impresses w/ soaring vaulted ceilings, while a custom built-in pantry adds charm & exceptional storage. Completing the 1st floor is an updated full bath & convenient 1st-floor laundry. Upstairs, a spacious landing continues the home's timeless appeal w/ more beautiful hardwood flooring. The primary bedroom offers 2 closets, while 2 additional bedrooms provide generous closet space. The main bath is a showpiece, featuring a soaking tub beneath a large window overlooking the lush backyard, a tiled subway shower w/ glass doors, & a vanity that blends classic charm w/ modern finishes. This one-of-a-kind property offers historic charm, thoughtful updates, exceptional outdoor living, & nearly 5 acres to enjoy, making it so much more than just a home. Del Neg 7/28 11am

956 Willits Rd, Ontario

$199,900

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1695269 MLS

Charming lakeside YEAR ROUND cottage offering 1,144 square feet of comfortable living space with beautiful lake views and endless potential. This two-story home features 2 bedrooms, 1 full bath, and a warm, inviting atmosphere perfect for seasonal getaways or year-round enjoyment. A detached garage provides additional storage for vehicles, recreational equipment, or workshop space. The property also includes a versatile spare room at the rear of the home that could be converted into additional living space, a family room, home office, or guest accommodations to suit your needs. Enjoy relaxing mornings overlooking the lake and peaceful evenings taking in the scenic surroundings. Whether you're looking for a weekend retreat, investment opportunity, or a place to make your own, this cottage offers the perfect combination of character location, and potential.

2168 1st Avenue, Ontario

$269,900

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1696255 MLS

3,364 SQ. FT. HOME • 7.83 ACRES • HUGE POND • MASSIVE BARN • ONLY $269,900! — Country Living at an Incredible Price! Have you been searching for acreage without breaking the bank? This is your opportunity to own a 7.83-acre private retreat with an impressive 792 feet of frontage on Arbor Road. A long private driveway leads to a spacious, solidly built 3,364-square-foot farmhouse featuring 4 bedrooms and 2 full baths. The property is surrounded by mature trees, walking trails, abundant wildlife, and a huge pond, creating a peaceful, park-like setting that is perfect for relaxing, exploring, or simply enjoying the outdoors. Whether you dream of gardening, raising animals, riding ATVs, or just having room to roam, this property offers the space and privacy that are becoming increasingly difficult to find. A massive 49' x 116' barn/shop provides tremendous potential for storage, hobbies, livestock, equipment, or a workshop. The barn does need repairs, but it offers an exceptional footprint and is ready for the next owner’s vision. Property Highlights 3,364 sq. ft. farmhouse 4 bedrooms 2 full baths 7.83 acres 792 feet of road frontage Long private driveway Huge pond Walking trails and abundant wildlife Plenty of room for horses and other animals Massive 49' x 116' barn/shop Wayne Central Schools

2720 Arbor Road Extension, Ontario

$999,900

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ R1693902 MLS

Welcome to 211 Lake Rd.,a truly rare opportunity to own one of Ontario's most exceptional waterfront Estates. Nestled on approximately 17 serene, private acres with an impressive 310 feet of Lake Ontario frontage, this remarkable property offers the perfect blend of luxury privacy and natural beauty. Stone pillars lead you down a quarter mile private drive to this historic Arts and Crafts style home. Enter to an expansive 30' x 25' living room featuring a stunning stone fireplace. Enjoy the glass enclosed sunroom. There's even a Butler's pantry! Gorgeous paned windows with rich wood molding span the entire home. The main residence features approximately 4100 ft.² of living space complemented by a separate approximately 1000 ft.² rental or guest residence, complete with a shuffleboard court! There's also a detached four car garage offering abundant storage for vehicles, recreational equipment or hobbies. A complete new HVAC system was installed in 2020. Enjoy breathtaking Lake views and beautiful sunsets while enjoying your stone lakeside patio with a fire pit. Mature grounds, wooded privacy and endless possibilities for recreation, entertaining or peaceful retreat living awaits. Whether you're seeking a year-round residence, family compound or waterfront escape this one of a kind property delivers an extraordinary lifestyle just minutes from local amenities. Former home of the City of Rochester Mayor Judge Adolph J Rodenback. Properties of this caliber, acreage and lake frontage seldom become available. Schedule your private tour today. DELAYED NEGOTIATIONS JULY 20TH, 2026, OFFERS DUE AT NOON.PLEASE GIVE 24 HOUR LIFE OF THE OFFER.

211 Lake Road, Ontario

$272,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1694770 MLS

Welcome to this spacious 4-bedroom, 2-full baths residence situated on a rare double-sized lot in a desirable lakeside neighborhood. This well maintained home offers plenty of room for family living and entertaining, along with the convenience of an attached one-car garage. The bright kitchen offers... sliding glass doors that open to a concrete patio, creating the perfect outdoor space for outdoor relaxing and enjoying the expansive backyard...Located just a five -minute walk to the lake and public boat docks...and with all the recreational activities waterfront living has to offer....Whether your looking for a year-round home or a weekend retreat..This property combines generous indoor and outdoor space with unbeatable location near water...Don't miss this opportunity to own a home in one of the area's most sought-after lake communities.

2163 Lake Road, Ontario

$649,900

10 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ R1692339 MLS

Beautifully updated 4-unit multifamily property situated on highly traveled Ridge Road in the Town of Ontario and located within the Wayne Central School District. This investment property offers four residential units with strong rental potential, making it a great option for investors or an owner-occupant looking to offset expenses. The property includes a rear deck, spacious yard, and four dedicated tenant storage areas. Additional income and tenant convenience are provided by the coin-operated washer and dryer. Exterior ADT security cameras are also in place, offering added security and peace of mind. With convenient access to shopping, local amenities, and major commuter routes, this property combines strong visibility with a neighborhood setting. Its established layout, Ridge Road exposure, and potential for rent growth or future improvements make it a solid addition to any investment portfolio.

1990 Ridge Road, Ontario

$349,999

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1675922 MLS

LAKE ONTARIO VIEW PROPERTY - DREAM LOCATION - Beautiful cozy 2 story home well maintained. 3 Bedrooms, 2 full baths with first floor laundry. Spacious Livingroom/ Dining with a cozy fireplace with lake view. Private deck with the view of the lake and access through a cute park (Thompson Park) and walking distance to Bear Creek with public boat launch. Detached garage that was converted into work shop but can be converted back into 2 car garage. This is a must see!! OPEN HOUSE SATURDAY JUNE 6 FROM 11:00 AM - 2:00 PM.

2187 Lake Road, Ontario

$150,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1671949 MLS

Affordable opportunity! This Colonial is situated on almost 3 acres with lots of woods. A great opportunity to add an out building! The house is solid but will need fixing up / remodeling. There is room to add a garage too. Located on a private drive so it is not right on Rt. 104. A very cool setting. This is a super opportunity to build equity with home ownership!

2555 State Route 104, Ontario

$63,500

R1658629 MLS

Build your next home or investment property on this prime half-acre vacant lot in the Village of Ontario. Measuring approximately 106’ x 236’, this residential multi-use zoned parcel allows for a two-family home and offers excellent potential for a walkout basement design. A major bonus for buyers: a home previously existed on the property, so water and sewer tap fees have already been paid—representing a significant cost savings. Conveniently located within walking distance to the post office, schools, library, town hall, Walgreens, convenience stores, restaurants, fitness facilities, and more. A rare opportunity to build in an established, walkable community.

1611 Ridge Rd, Ontario

Start Your Search

Ontario Historical Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for historical properties available in Ontario and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!