Browse All Webster NY Between $400K - $500K Properties for Sale

EXCEPTIONAL PRIVATE SETTING for this AMAZING HOME! QUIETLY TUCKED AWAY ON 1.88 WOODED ACRES with ALL THE CHARM & CHARACTER of YESTERYEAR, and MODERN CONVENIENCES OF TODAY! FALL IN LOVER from the MOMENT YOU SET EYES ON THIS RARE GEM! A STATELY CIRCULAR DRIVEWAY LEADS to this GORGEOUS 1930'S CIRCA COLONIAL with BEAUTIFUL "LAKE" STONE EXTERIOR! STEP INSIDE and you will be MORE IMPRESSED by the TIMELESS NATURAL WOOD DOORS, TRIM, MOLDINGS, AND HARDWOOD FLOORING THRU-OUT! A SPACIOUS LIVING ROOM OFFERS A BAY WINDOW OVERLOOKING the PARK-LIKE SURROUNDINGS, as well as an INCREDIBLE COBBLESTONE "GAS" FIRPLACE, BUILT-INS, and a GRAND "WINDING" STAIRCASE leading to the 2ND Floor * THE CUSTOM EAT-IN KITCHEN has been PERFECTLY UPDATED with HIGH-END MAPLE CABINETRY, GRANITE COUNTERS, TILE BACKSPLASH, LUXURY FLOORING, STAINLESS APPLIANCES, BREAKFAST BAR, and a NOOK with CRAFTED TABLE and BUILT-IN SEATING! FORMAL DINING with a BUILT-IN HUTCH leads to a WONDERFUL 3-SEASONS PORCH! FAMILY ROOM w/PEGGED OAK HARDWOODS has a MODERN BATH with an OVERSIZED SHOWER ENCLOSURE - COULD EASILY BE A 1ST FLOOR PRIMARY BEDROOM with ENSUITE BATH * There is also a 1ST FLOOR HALF BATH *2ND FLOOR offers a LARGE PRIMARY BEDROOM with an ATTACHED SUN PORCH/SUMMER BEDROOM *TWO ADDITIONAL BEDROOMS and a FULLY REFRESHED BATH with RICH CHERRY CABINETRY, SOLID SURFACE COUNTER, TUB-SHOWER COMBO, and HEATED TILE FLOORING! THERE IS ALSO STAIR ACCESS to the PARTIALLY FINISHED unheated ATTIC * FULL WALK-OUT BASEMENT has a FINISHED REC-ROOM with BEAUTIFUL WALLS of BLENDED OAK, MAHOGANY, & PINE . . . WOODBURNING STOVE (AS-IS), LAUNDRY, WORKSHOP, and UTILITY ROOM *THREE (3) CAR DETACHED GARAGE with 2-ELECTRIC OPENERS & RECENT OVERHEAD DOORS *CENTRAL VAC * HI-EFF FURNACE & A/C (2011) *WATER HTR (2014) * COPPER GUTTERS & ROOF over entrance * THERMOPANE WINDOWS * RECENTLY PAVED DRIVEWAY with PARKING AREA *GREEN LIGHT INTERNET *CLOSE TO LAKE, BAY, MARINA, NATURE TRAILS, WEBSTER TOWN PARK * SHOWINGS START FRIDAY 09/11 2026 *NEGOTIATIONS ON THURS 9/17/2026 @ 12 NOON * PLEASE ALLOW 24 HRS FOR SELLER TO RESPOND * OPEN HOUSE SATURDAY 09/12 FROM 12:30 to 2:00 pm . . . WATCH THE VIDEO!!!!

560 Van Alstyne Road, Webster

$459,900

2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1711660 MLS

Out with the 80's and in with 2026, a completely renovated townhome. A full restoration offers a new custom layout with updates throughout. From the bright two-story foyer, you’ll see through to the spacious two-story living room. Newly updated lighting, fixtures/devices, hardware, and solid 3/4-inch white oak hardwood flooring runs through the entire first floor and second floor grand loft/ hallway. The stylishly remodeled eat in kitchen offers new stainless-steel appliances, new cabinetry, and spacious island for entertaining. The quartz countertops and backsplash will wow guests, especially the pot filler over a professional grade 36” gas range with air fryer. Chef’s will enjoy the easy reach built-in microwave and an in-island beverage cooler. Inspired by mid-century modern design the custom fireplace surround will display your décor all year round. A first-floor full bath will accommodate guests comfortably, for everyday living, or possibly a doggy wash. Bring a book to the second-floor loft area made for seating or writing desk. Retreat to the sophisticated primary suite, completely remodeled to be a true primary suite. A quiet color palette, soaring ceilings, natural light, generous walk-in closet, and fandelier sets the stage to relax. The primary ensuite feels like a luxury get away. This spa-like full bath features double shower heads/handheld sprayer, double vanities, and all new fixtures. The half bath is steps away from the second bedroom with all new fixtures and carpeting. A finished basement not included in square footage also offers all new carpeting, lighting, fixtures/devices, and a flex area to suit your needs. A could be theater room, a gym, with secondary room for large walk-in closet or storage. This includes a laundry area with plenty of storage. This West Webster community is near shopping, interstate, medical, entertainment, dining, and much more. Carefree living starts from the garage with new epoxied garage floor, fresh paint, storage and new garage door opener/keypad. Be sure to watch the virtual walk-through video.

396 Spinnaker Lane, Webster

$474,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1709375 MLS

Welcome to 1093 Bear Creek Trail, where modern living meets a truly exceptional setting. Tucked away at the end of a quiet cul-de-sac, this beautifully maintained, just two-year-old home offers the perfect blend of privacy, nature, and convenience. Step inside to an inviting open floor plan designed for both everyday living and entertaining. The spacious layout features three bedrooms and two full bathrooms, with bright, comfortable living spaces that flow seamlessly together. The kitchen and living areas overlook the serene backyard, bringing the beauty of the outdoors in. The real showpiece of this property is the setting. Step onto the Trex deck and take in peaceful pond views surrounded by woods, creating a backyard retreat that feels private and tranquil. Enjoy watching wildlife right from home, from birds and deer to the many visitors nature brings throughout the seasons. Looking for future potential? The walkout basement with daylight windows is already plumbed for a future finish, offering endless possibilities for additional living space, a guest suite, a home gym, or an entertainment area. If you’ve been searching for newer construction without sacrificing character, privacy, or scenery, this is the one you’ve been waiting for. Seller to provide a 1-year home warranty to buyer. NO DELAYS! MAKE AN OFFER TODAY!

1093 Bear Creek Circle, Webster

$495,000

R1703286 MLS

THIS 12.7 ACRE WOODED PARCEL IS IN A PRIME AREA WITH ACCESS FROM WOODHULL AND SR 250. GREAT LOCATION CLOSE TO SHOPPING, SCHOOLS, PARK, AND LAKE. GAS, ELECTRIC, WATER AVAILABLE. IDEAL FOR A FAMILY ESTATE OR SPLIT INTO LOTS.

325 Webster Rd Road, Webster

$415,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1701172 MLS

Welcome home to this beautifully maintained 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath Colonial offering approximately 1,850 square feet of comfortable living space in one of Webster's most desirable neighborhoods. Perfectly situated on over a half-acre, this exceptional property backs to forever wild land, providing peaceful views and unmatched privacy to enjoy from your patio. From the moment you arrive, you'll appreciate the pride of ownership that shines throughout. Gleaming hardwood floors flow across the first level, while new carpeting adds warmth and comfort upstairs. The inviting family room features a classic wood-burning fireplace, creating the perfect gathering place on cool evenings.The kitchen has been tastefully refreshed with resurfaced cabinetry, blending timeless style with everyday functionality. Thoughtful updates continue outside with a resurfaced driveway, beautifully designed patio and landscaping, and a newer storage shed for all of your gardening and outdoor equipment. The partially finished basement offers additional flexible living space - ideal for a recreation room, home office, exercise area, or playroom. Enjoy the serenity of nature in your own backyard while remaining just minutes from Webster's parks, shopping, restaurants, and schools. If you've been searching for a lovely cared-for home in a wonderful neighborhood with privacy, beautiful surroundings, and tasteful updates, this Colonial is one you won't want to miss.

1454 Chigwell Lane N, Webster

$499,900

R1688479 MLS

RARE OPPORTUNITY IN WEBSTER! Offering 3.84 acres of RESIDENTIALLY ZONED LAND to be subdivided from the existing 4.8-acre property at 610 Webster Road. This versatile parcel presents a unique opportunity for builders, investors, or those looking to create a PRIVATE HOMESITE with room to grow. The property may be purchased as a single 3.84-acre parcel with the potential for further SUBDIVISION into 2 or 3 building lots (subject to approvals), or the sellers will consider selling individual building lots separately--lot sizes are negotiable. Two EXISTING OUTBUILDINGS are included offering the potential for STORAGE--a 26x55 one-story frame building with concrete pad and a 80x30 two-story masonry building. PUBLIC WATER, SEWER, ELECTRIC, and natural GAS are AVAILABLE at the road, providing added convenience for future development. Enjoy a peaceful setting with WOODED privacy along the rear of the property while remaining close to Webster's many amenities, shopping, parks, and schools.

610 Webster Rd, Webster

$479,900

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1680787 MLS

Expect to be impressed! This 2,490-sq ft, Colonial blends classic symmetry with comfortable, family-friendly living. The home features four spacious bedrooms and two-and-a-half baths, a layout that balances formal gathering spaces with everyday functionality. The front exterior showcases timeless Colonial architecture with a centered main entrance framed by evenly spaced windows and traditional detailing. A welcoming foyer opens into a thoughtfully designed main level that typically includes a formal living room, dining room, and a generously sized family room ideal for entertaining or relaxing., and a quiet sitting room for study, or home office. Large windows throughout the home bring in abundant natural light and create an airy, inviting atmosphere. The kitchen serves as the heart of the home, with ample cabinetry, counter space, and a center island for additional food prep, or room for casual dining. Flowing seamlessly from the interior living areas, French glass doors lead to an impressive spanning rear deck that stretches across much of the back of the house. This outdoor living space provides plenty of room for dining, grilling, lounging, and hosting gatherings. Adjacent to the deck is a well-maintained above-ground pool, creating a private backyard retreat perfect for summer enjoyment. The combination of the oversized deck and pool area makes the outdoor space ideal for entertaining family and friends. Upstairs, the four bedrooms offer comfortable accommodation, including a spacious primary suite complete with a private full bath and generous closet space. The additional bedrooms are versatile for family, guests, or home office use, while a second full bath serves the remaining rooms efficiently. Highlights include a convenient first-floor powder room, an attached garage and a backyard designed for recreation and relaxation. All this in the quaint town of Webster, close to shopping, dining, expressways, and the sought after Webster schools.

644 Yardley Court, Webster

Start Your Search

Between $400K - $500K Webster Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for between $400k - $500k properties available in Webster and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!