Quick Webster NY MLS Search

Browse All Webster NY Historical Properties for Sale

$449,000
3 Beds 3 Baths R1713290 MLS
EXCEPTIONAL PRIVATE SETTING for this AMAZING HOME! QUIETLY TUCKED AWAY ON 1.88 WOODED ACRES with ALL THE CHARM & CHARACTER of YESTERYEAR, and MODERN CONVENIENCES OF TODAY! FALL IN LOVER from the MOMENT YOU SET EYES ON THIS RARE GEM! A STATELY CIRCULAR DRIVEWAY LEADS to this GORGEOUS 1930'S CIRCA COLONIAL with BEAUTIFUL "LAKE" STONE EXTERIOR! STEP INSIDE and you will be MORE IMPRESSED by the TIMELESS NATURAL WOOD DOORS, TRIM, MOLDINGS, AND HARDWOOD FLOORING THRU-OUT! A SPACIOUS LIVING ROOM OFFERS A BAY WINDOW OVERLOOKING the PARK-LIKE SURROUNDINGS, as well as an INCREDIBLE COBBLESTONE "GAS" FIRPLACE, BUILT-INS, and a GRAND "WINDING" STAIRCASE leading to the 2ND Floor * THE CUSTOM EAT-IN KITCHEN has been PERFECTLY UPDATED with HIGH-END MAPLE CABINETRY, GRANITE COUNTERS, TILE BACKSPLASH, LUXURY FLOORING, STAINLESS APPLIANCES, BREAKFAST BAR, and a NOOK with CRAFTED TABLE and BUILT-IN SEATING! FORMAL DINING with a BUILT-IN HUTCH leads to a WONDERFUL 3-SEASONS PORCH! FAMILY ROOM w/PEGGED OAK HARDWOODS has a MODERN BATH with an OVERSIZED SHOWER ENCLOSURE - COULD EASILY BE A 1ST FLOOR PRIMARY BEDROOM with ENSUITE BATH * There is also a 1ST FLOOR HALF BATH *2ND FLOOR offers a LARGE PRIMARY BEDROOM with an ATTACHED SUN PORCH/SUMMER BEDROOM *TWO ADDITIONAL BEDROOMS and a FULLY REFRESHED BATH with RICH CHERRY CABINETRY, SOLID SURFACE COUNTER, TUB-SHOWER COMBO, and HEATED TILE FLOORING! THERE IS ALSO STAIR ACCESS to the PARTIALLY FINISHED unheated ATTIC * FULL WALK-OUT BASEMENT has a FINISHED REC-ROOM with BEAUTIFUL WALLS of BLENDED OAK, MAHOGANY, & PINE . . . WOODBURNING STOVE (AS-IS), LAUNDRY, WORKSHOP, and UTILITY ROOM *THREE (3) CAR DETACHED GARAGE with 2-ELECTRIC OPENERS & RECENT OVERHEAD DOORS *CENTRAL VAC * HI-EFF FURNACE & A/C (2011) *WATER HTR (2014) * COPPER GUTTERS & ROOF over entrance * THERMOPANE WINDOWS * RECENTLY PAVED DRIVEWAY with PARKING AREA *GREEN LIGHT INTERNET *CLOSE TO LAKE, BAY, MARINA, NATURE TRAILS, WEBSTER TOWN PARK * SHOWINGS START FRIDAY 09/11 2026 *NEGOTIATIONS ON THURS 9/17/2026 @ 12 NOON * PLEASE ALLOW 24 HRS FOR SELLER TO RESPOND * OPEN HOUSE SATURDAY 09/12 FROM 12:30 to 2:00 pm . . . WATCH THE VIDEO!!!!

560 Van Alstyne Road, Webster

$379,900
5 Beds 2 Baths R1713147 MLS
Welcome to 1877 Ridge Rd—a rare opportunity to own a home where CHARACTER, SPACE & LOCATION come together beautifully! With 2,874 SF of living space, this remarkable Victorian-era home offers the versatility of 4–5 bedrooms, including a possible 1ST FLR BEDROOM, 2 FULL BATHS, and 1ST or 2ND FLR LAUNDRY--there's even a laundry hook-up in the basement. The CRAFTSMANSHIP of its era remains evident in the home’s ORIGINAL WOODWORK, gracious foyer, stained-glass details and distinctive staircase. These are the architectural touches that give this home a warmth and personality that simply cannot be replicated today. Two ENCLOSED PORCHES add living space & convenience—enjoy your morning coffee or afternoon tea in the inviting THREE-SEASON FRONT PORCH. The convenient rear porch provides an enclosed, practical transition into the home and a protected place for package deliveries. The property offers additional functionality with a detached two-story, 2.5-CAR GARAGE/OUTBUILDING, providing generous space for vehicles, equipment & storage--the 2nd floor has a BASKETBALL COURT and offers other recreational opportunities. Beyond the front door, the property becomes its own private retreat, with established gardens and mature surroundings. Located in the Webster School District with convenient access to local restaurants, shopping, and area expressways. Just a short walk away is a 71-acre nature preserve with walkable trails providing the opportunity to enjoy nature close to home. This one deserves a closer look! Open Friday 9/11 & Sunday 9/13. Delayed negotiations on 9/16 after 12 pm.

1877 Ridge Road, Webster

$695,000
4 Beds 4 Baths R1711257 MLS
Very unique investment property located on the Webster Golf Club featuring a 4 family consisting of Four 1 bedroom units, an 11,000 sf 3 story barn and possibility of subdividing off a half acre building lot. Barn use is on a variance. This property backs up to the Webster Golf Club. This has been in the same family ownership for over 100 yrs. The 4-Family includes 2 apartments on the 1st floor and 2 on the second floor. 2 are larger units and 2 are smaller units. Rents include all utilities and property maintenance. The largest one is on the 2nd floor and includes a deck overlooking the golf course and its own washer & dryer. Plenty of parking is available. All units are in move- in ready condition. The Barn is 3 stories and in excellent condition. The lower-level space comprises of a shop area with storage and connected to a wood framed and steel storage building all with overhead doors and sliding doors. The main floor of the barn has an 1120 sf heated and air-conditioned office. There is a private office, reception room, a workroom, a kitchenette and a full bathroom. The remaining 1st floor is storage with an overhead door. The huge loft is also used for storage. The exterior has been recently painted and a full new tear-off roof with all new sheathing was done last year. There is also a loading platform for tractor trailer deliveries. Investment Considerations Strengths: Rare combination of residential + commercial/flex space + land Long family ownership suggests stable, well-maintained asset Recent roof and exterior work = deferred maintenance largely addressed Golf course adjacency adds scarcity value All units rent-ready with utilities included (simple landlord experience)

468 Salt Road, Webster

$329,900
4 Beds 2 Baths R1707112 MLS
This is not your typical estate sale! This lovely home is truly move-in ready—freshly painted, thoroughly cleaned from top to bottom, and power washed outside, including the walkways and deck. The spacious eat-in kitchen is centrally located between the living room/dining room and family room. A vaulted ceiling highlights the bright and open family room, which leads to the air-conditioned three-season room, where French doors open to the fully fenced yard and deck. Updated windows with custom blinds throughout add to the home's appeal. The main floor offers a bedroom, full bath, and laundry room, making one-floor living an option. The laundry room was originally a bedroom and could easily be converted back to provide a second first-floor bedroom or fourth bedroom, with additional laundry hookups available in the basement. Upstairs are two generously sized bedrooms and a half bath with plenty of room to add a tub or shower if desired. Additional features include an attached two-car garage with additional workshop space, a large driveway with convenient turnaround, central air, automatic standby generator, and LOW property taxes! Thinking about adding a pool? The electrical is already in place. The roof was a complete tear-off replacement with a 50-year shingle. Items to remain and are included in the sale in as-is condition are all Kitchen appliances, custom kitchen table and chairs, window treatments, basement washer and dryer, family room wall-mounted TV, work benches, tool cabinets and ladders. First-floor washer and dryer are negotiable.

831 Bay Road, Webster

$1,200,000
R1707037 MLS
IMAGINE WHAT COULD GO HERE. Not just another property. Not just another house. A rare 1.7-acre opportunity in one of Webster’s most coveted commercial corridors—where Ridge Road meets the Empire Boulevard sweet spot. The existing house and barn are not the story here. The land is. The location is. The possibilities are. Picture a high-visibility destination that takes advantage of the steady traffic and exposure along one of Webster’s busiest and most established commercial areas. Picture a medical or professional office campus. A retail destination. An automotive concept. A mixed-use development. Residential incorporated into a thoughtfully designed commercial setting. Or something entirely different that hasn’t even been imagined yet. With 1.7 acres, you have room to think beyond the footprint of what exists today. The property is located within Webster’s Progressive Development Overlay District (PDD), offering increased flexibility and a broader range of potential uses, including retail, office, medical, automotive, and mixed-use/residential development. Utilities are available, adding another layer of opportunity to an already compelling site. And perhaps most importantly, you are buying into the location. A prominent Ridge Road address. Excellent visibility. High traffic volume. Immediate access to the established Empire Boulevard commercial corridor. A setting where businesses benefit from being seen—and where development has the potential to become part of the landscape for years to come. Walk the property and don't look at what is there. Look at what could be there. Because this isn't about the house. It isn't about the barn. It's about 1.7 acres of possibility in a location that doesn't come available often.

671 Ridge Road, Webster

$319,000
3 Beds 2 Baths R1704004 MLS
There is just something about this special home that FEELS LIKE HOME! Tucked into the Village of Webster, just 1/4 mile from the heart of the village and within close distance of State Road Elementary and Spry Middle School, this comfortable Cape Cod has 5-star curb appeal and the kind of warmth you notice the minute you walk through the door. A handsome new front door and open foyer welcome you inside, where rich hardwood floors run throughout the first floor. The spacious living room is bright and inviting with a substantial bay window and a WOODBURNING FIREPLACE featuring a carved mantel and tile hearth. It flows easily into the dining room, which has a pass-through to the kitchen and a door to the coveted 3-season room/enclosed porch. The kitchen offers loads of hickory cabinetry, including charming glass-front cabinets, updated appliances and plenty of storage. TWO FIRST-FLOOR BEDROOMS and a FULL BATH make FIRST FLOOR LIVING POSSIBLE and a guest area or a home office easy. Wait until you see upstairs! The entire second floor is a sprawling PRIMARY SUITE with a sitting area, walk-in closet and private full bath that includes a SOAKING TUB and NEW GLASS SHOWER. Our favorite part?  French doors open to your own PRIVATE BALCONY overlooking the backyard and fire pit—a surprisingly special little hideaway! Outside is just as lovely, with tidy landscaping (including a butterfly bush that delivers!) 2-car garage, shed, and a covered deck/eating area tucked beneath the garage overhang—perfect for summer dining or a shady spot to relax. The large, dry basement offers excellent storage plus a great workshop. The important updates are already done: TEAR-OFF ROOF 2018, ALL NEW ANDERSEN WINDOWS 2024, beautiful front and storm doors 2023, and furnace 2010. Comfortable, welcoming and wonderfully located, this is one of those houses that simply feels good to be in—and you can WALK TO THE VILLAGE! Open Sat 8-29-26 (12-2pm) Note: Public records show the square footage as 1648, the seller states that the true square footage is 1800.

37 Fuller Avenue, Webster

$390,000
3 Beds 3 Baths R1702111 MLS
Beautifully Updated 3-Bedroom Ranch with Resort-Style Backyard in Webster! This move-in-ready home has been completely updated and offers the perfect blend of modern finishes, functional living space, and an incredible outdoor retreat. Major updates include a new roof, new siding, new gutters, new windows, new front door, and new interior doors, fresh interior paint, new flooring throughout, beautifully remodeled bathrooms, new quartz countertops in the kitchen and all-new stainless steel appliances. The spacious floor plan features a large family room, formal dining room, and a bright eat-in kitchen designed for everyday living and entertaining. Enjoy the convenience of first-floor laundry hookups, with an additional laundry area available in the basement. The expansive finished walk-out basement provides exceptional additional living space and opens directly to the backyard pool area, making it ideal for entertaining, a recreation room, home office, or gym. An additional room beneath the garage offers plenty of space for storage, hobbies, or a workshop (440 sq.ft. under garage.) Approximately, 1200 sq.ft. of additional finished space in the basement. Step outside to your own private backyard oasis featuring a huge freshly painted in-ground pool with a new concrete patio. The large, private yard provides plenty of room for outdoor games, gardening, or relaxing with family and friends. A beautifully landscaped rock garden and winding pathway create a picturesque setting leading to the pool. Located just minutes from the Village of Webster, you'll enjoy easy access to local shops, restaurants, parks, farmers markets, and year-round community events. Convenient to major highways for an easy commute, yet tucked away in a peaceful setting that offers the charm and privacy of country living. This truly turnkey home has all the major updates already completed—just move in and start enjoying everything this exceptional Webster property has to offer!

1562 Ridge Road, Webster

$320,000
4 Beds 2 Baths R1701405 MLS
Step back in time and discover the charm, craftsmanship, and premium modernization at 1440 Ridge Road in Webster. This home was enjoyed by 1 family for the past 65 years. Built in 1913, this home offers over 2,000 sq ft of living space featuring original chestnut woodwork, timeless details, and craftsmanship that simply cannot be reproduced. The layout features a living room with a cozy brick hearth, a formal dining room with bay windows, 4 bedrooms, and 1.5 baths. Chimney for fireplace entirely replaced in 1990. The interior is rich with unique storage: a multi-level laundry chute, built-in clothes/linen cabinets, chestnut built-ins, and dual-sided display cabinetry. Enjoy seasonal living at its absolute finest on the expansive screened front porch with a new Ipe/Brazilian Walnut floor, a covered back porch, or the second-story primary balcony porch. A highlight is the detached two-story carriage house/garage, updated in 2006 with a new full foundation while preserving its turn-of-the-century charm. The upper level provides 2 car parking, while the full walkout lower level offers an exceptional workshop complete with a 100-amp electrical service, multi-voltage receptacles, and preparation for a two-story dust collection system. The lower level opens directly to a new concrete patio with pre-installed underground gas lines for an easy shop heater hookup. The main home's walkout basement provides additional living space, while the massive walk-up attic offers exciting expansion potential. Fully blown-in insulation throughout the home and attic. Smart updates include dual-zoned heating, central air, Honeywell internet thermostats, and a full tear-off roof on a durable plywood base. For economical upkeep of this grand structure, the third-floor exterior features maintenance-free vinyl siding and aluminum trim. Nearly a half-acre deep lot is a serene gardening oasis complete with arbors for Concord, Niagara, and seedless grapes. The yard also features cold-hardy kiwis, raspberries, gooseberries, and mature Carpathian walnuts offering large annual harvests. 1440 Ridge Road is a rare opportunity to own a piece of Webster's history.

1440 Ridge Road, Webster

$274,900
5 Beds 3 Baths R1696787 MLS
More Room & More Room! This Remarkable Ranch Gives You All The Space You Need To Stretch Out & Relax! Big & Bright Living Room Is a Welcoming Area to Stretch Out and Opens Up to the Kitchen & Dining Room Making This A Perfect Home For Entraining Family & Friends! Spacious & Gracious Formal Dining Room for All of Your Holiday & Specially Occasion Needs! Delightful Eat In Kitchen Features an Inviting Breakfast Bar with a generous Seating Area! Just Down the Hall You'll Discover the Home's 4 First-Floor Bedrooms and 2 Full Baths - There's Literally a Room For Everyone & Everything! The Finished Lower Level Features an Additional 506+ Sq Ft with 2 Egress Windows and a Walk Out Door Creating a Total of 2,203+ Sq Ft! HUGE Lower Level Family Rec Room is Perfect for Relaxing, Hobbies, & Working Out! Additional 5th Bedroom or IN Home Office Space is Perfect for Tele-Commuting to Work. And the Homes 3rd Full Bath Makes Using All The Extra Lower Level Space Easy & Convenient! Fresh Neutral Decor & Paint Throughout, All New Wall to Wall Carpeting! Terrific Back Yard is Perfect for Pets & Play and Features an Expansive Deck for All Your 3-Season Entertainment & Outdoor Living Needs! Convenient Attached 2 Car Garage, Maintenance Free Vinyl Siding, Energy Efficient Vinyl Thermal Pane Windows, NEW Tear Off Roof 2019, NEW Furnace & Central Air Conditioning 2018, Updated Electrical Panel, and So Much More! HURRY! You're Going TO LOVE Calling This House "HOME!"

280 Wellington Road, Webster

Start Your Search

Webster Historical Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for historical properties available in Webster and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!