Browse All Rochester NY Between $400K - $500K Properties for Sale

A NEW HOME FOR THE HOLIDAYS! Welcome Home to this Rarely Available End Unit, Centrally Located Townhome in a Small Private Community! Literally Steps to the Eastman House and All Park Avenue Restaurants and Activities! This Exceptional Home Offers the Perfect Blend of Convenience, Comfort and Privacy-Tucked Away in a Peaceful Setting that Makes You Forget You're in the City. The Spacious Living Room Features a Woodburning Fireplace with a Classic Marble Mantle and Beautiful Hardwood Floors Overlooking the Lush Rear Yard and Gardens. The Formal Dining Area Offers Sliding Glass Doors that Leads to the Patio, Creating an Effortless Flow for Entertaining and Outdoor Enjoyment. The Beautifully Updated Kitchen Features Solid Surface Counters, Pantry and Warm Cork Flooring. A Newly Updated Guest Bath Completes the First Floor. Upstairs, the Light-Filled, Large Primary Suite is a True Retreat, Complete with Private Bath and Wall of Closets. 2 Additional Bedrooms, A Full Bath and Extra Convenient Second Floor Laundry Complete the Upper Level. A Coveted, Attached 2 Car Garage and a Full Basement Provide Exceptional Storage and Everyday Convenience. Outside the Private Yard and Inviting Stone Patio Create a Tranquil Oasis Surrounded by Gardens and Greenery. A Rare Opportunity to Enjoy Spacious Townhome Living in a Private, Serene Setting While Remaining Close to Literally All Eastside Amenities. Live in the Heart of it All! Delayed Negotiations Until 9/16/26 @ 6PM. 24 Hour Response Requested.**There is no sign on this property**

24 Barrington Park, Rochester

$475,000

4 Beds ⋅ R1703294 MLS

Another Rockin' Rochester Property! This 6 Unit home in the Beechwood neighborhood features two studios, 4 one bedroom units. Seller pays utilities. The boiler is about 10 years old, roof is about 19 years old, new vinyl siding, new thermopane windows. Located on corner of Arch St, just two blocks from the border of N Winton Village. Gross Annual Income of $54,097! New C of O at closing.

1596-1598 E Main Street, Rochester

$449,900

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1708524 MLS

Welcome to 215 Crosman Terrace, a character-rich historic Colonial offering more than 2,200 square feet in Rochester’s desirable Upper Monroe neighborhood. This 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home blends original architectural detail with thoughtful improvements, featuring hardwood floors, leaded glass, high ceilings, crown moldings and abundant natural light. The spacious layout includes a sunroom, formal dining area, eat-in kitchen and a beautifully finished attic providing exceptional additional living, office or creative space with its own mini-split for heating and cooling. The finished basement adds even more flexibility for recreation, fitness, workshop or storage needs. Outside, enjoy a private backyard with deck, patio, mature hedging, native pollinator gardens and fieldstone beds, plus a detached 2-car garage and additional driveway parking. Updates include attic and basement spray-foam insulation, hot water tank, chimney reflashing, gutters, window pulley and leaded-glass repairs, attic renovation and more. Conveniently located near Monroe Avenue, Highland Park, Cobbs Hill Park, neighborhood restaurants, coffee shops and amenities. Classic Rochester architecture, generous space and a location that keeps you connected to the best of city living.

215 Crosman Terrace, Rochester

$475,000

R1706479 MLS

Fantastic opportunity for any investor or business owner/operator! Established and profitable restaurant with 25 parking spaces and three apartments. Perfect for a restaurant owner/operator, no need to pay someone a lease when you can have tenants pay your mortgage! Kitchen area is well maintained and in fabulous shape! Restaurant approved for seating up to 72 customers, all restaurant furniture and equipment will convey with sale. All seperate utilities. Apartments each have their own off street parking spaces seperate from restaurant parking. Includes two additional lots with purchase. Owner financing potentially available for exceptionally qualified buyers. Owner willing to sell restaurant business with property. New roof, two newer boilers, and newer hot water tanks.

3212 Lake Avenue, Rochester

$457,500

2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1697344 MLS

Experience low-maintenance city living in the heart of Rochester's Central Business District at the sought-after Symphony Terrace townhomes! This well-maintained 2-bedroom, 2.5-bath multi-level townhouse offers 1,720 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space in a charming courtyard setting just steps from theatre, restaurants, shopping, entertainment, and the renowned Eastman School of Music. The ground level welcomes you with a private entrance, attached 1-car garage, and generous storage space. Upstairs, the main living level is designed for everyday living and entertaining, featuring beautiful hardwood floors, an open-concept living and dining area, a convenient half bath, and a functional galley kitchen. The upper level offers two generously sized bedrooms, each with its own private full bath, creating an ideal layout for guests, roommates, or working professionals. The spacious primary suite includes a walk-in closet, laundry conveniently located within the ensuite bath, and a staircase leading to a versatile loft—perfect for a home office, reading nook, fitness area, or creative studio. Step outside to enjoy your own private patio overlooking the beautifully maintained courtyard, providing a peaceful retreat in the heart of the city. The HOA handles courtyard maintenance and snow removal, allowing you to spend more time enjoying everything downtown Rochester has to offer. Whether you're looking for a full-time residence or a lock-and-leave lifestyle, this exceptional Symphony Terrace townhouse offers the perfect combination of comfort, convenience, and walkable urban living.

12 Grove Street, Rochester

$400,000

R1700530 MLS

A rare opportunity! Located South East of City Center in the Upper Monroe Neighborhood. This beautiful property features stunning architectural details, soaring ceilings, and stained glass windows. Throughout the building you will find several common rooms, office spaces, and additional rooms for classrooms or community gatherings. A Large Kitchen w/Commercial Hood & Fire Suppressant system (2023). A cultural center featuring a balcony and stage. 3rd floor has been converted to an apartment. Recently installed Handicap Accessible features include Ramp, Chair Lift, and Elevator. Whether you’re looking to continue its use as a place of worship, or repurpose for creative redevelopment, the potential is limitless. Very unique location. R3 Zoning, abutting 3 zoning districts. Current permitted uses include Multi-Family Dwellings, Live-Work Space, Bed & Breakfast, Child or Adult Day Care, and more. Buyers should contact Rochester City Zoning for potential property uses. Conveniently located near major highways, amenities and a few mins walk to Cobbs Hill. Some photos are virtually staged.

1006 Monroe Avenue, Rochester

$424,900

6 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1697913 MLS

Located in the desirable ABC streets on the east side of Rochester, near Cobbs Hill. Large majestic classic Park Avenue area home with 2590 sq. ft. This is a 6 bedroom 2.5 bath, well maintained home. Lge front porch, lrg porch off primary bedroom. 2 large foyers in front and back of the home. Double staircase. All hardwood floors through out the whole house and are completely refinished. Decorative fireplace in livingroom. Many lead glass windows throughout the home. on all 3 floors the interior has been freshly painted. All current appliances stay with the house. Tear-off roof & H20 tank less than 1 year old. 5 car parking. Ceder shake siding and brick foundation makes for easy maintenence. This is a lovely home and feels much larger than the stated sq. footage. Do not miss this house!

923 Harvard Street, Rochester

$499,900

R1688526 MLS

Exceptional investment opportunity in the City of Rochester! This fully occupied mixed-use commercial property offers immediate positive cash flow with minimal maintenance concerns thanks to extensive renovations completed throughout the building. The property features 2 commercial storefronts and 3 residential apartments, including a studio, one-bedroom, and two-bedroom, all currently occupied producing over $6,300/mo. in rent. Photos were taken after renovation, before tenants moved in. C of O good through 12/28. Recent improvements include NEW windows, kitchens, bathrooms, mini-split systems throughout, flooring, ceilings, and more, creating a truly turnkey investment opportunity. The comprehensive updates provide peace of mind for investors while helping reduce future maintenance expenses. Ideally located in the City of Rochester, this income-producing property offers convenient access to public transportation, shopping, dining, employment centers, and major highways, making it an attractive location for both residential and commercial tenants. Residents and business owners alike can enjoy everything Rochester has to offer while benefiting from easy commuting options. Whether you're expanding your portfolio or seeking a stable, cash-flowing asset, this fully leased mixed-use property delivers strong income potential, updated systems, and a prime location in one of Rochester's established neighborhoods. Group showings offered Fri, 6/12 1p-2p and Mon. 6/15 1p-2p.

1274-1278 Dewey Avenue, Rochester

$488,900

6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ R1688322 MLS

Completely transformed and move in ready!!! Located just minutes from great restaurants, boutique shopping, cafes, and popular local hotspots. This lovingly-maintained multifamily property offers strong rental potential and is an excellent addition to any portfolio—ideal for both new and experienced investors. The Rare, first-floor unit features a private porch, three bedrooms, two full bathrooms, and the convenience of in-unit laundry. Upstairs, there is a spacious two-bedroom, one-bath apartment, along with a separate one-bedroom, one-bath unit next door. The one-bedroom apartment also includes complimentary laundry access in the basement. Each unit offers comfortable living space with updated kitchens and bathrooms, making this property appealing to both tenants and owner-occupants. Additional highlights include individual electrical panel boxes, updated windows, gutters, laminate flooring, and fresh interior finishes throughout. Making this property a true turnkey investment!

399 E University Avenue W Unit 397, Rochester

$449,000

6 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1686354 MLS

Welcome to this beautiful well maintained home. Home recently appraised for 440,000 This fully furnished, tenant-occupied property offers a seamless investment opportunity with immediate rental income. So many updates kitchen, bathrooms, fresh paint, and a brand-new tear off roof was installed and comes with a transferable warranty. Please allow 24 hours for all appointments.

59 Rowley Street, Rochester

$499,999

R1684667 MLS

Now offering River Campus Storage, a premier climate controlled self-storage facility in Rochester, NY. This property offers an exceptional investment opportunity with a robust client base, modern amenities, and a prime location near the University of Rochester. The property was renovated in 2018 to offer 115 climate controlled units over two floors with a total of 8,675 Net Rentable SF. Size of units range from small lockers (5x5), to large storage spaces (14x19), and outside parking lot, accommodating a variety of storage needs. Leasing office onsite for new management to occupy. 24/7 video surveillance, electronic gate code access, and a well-lit premises ensures the safety and peace of mind for all tenants. HVAC updated in 2017/18 including (2) new electric furnaces, and (6) dual-zone mini split systems. This property offers newcomers to the self storage industry potential to finance with an SBA loan with only 10% down. Reach out for more information.

169 Flanders Street, Rochester

$500,000

R1614789 MLS

Investors! Take advantage of this rare opportunity to own a stylish, fully occupied office building in a prime Rochester location. Offering excellent visibility and a flexible layout, the property features a thoughtful mix of private offices and open work areas filled with natural light and modern finishes. Multiple access points provide privacy and convenience for occupants, while a dedicated parking lot directly across the street adds valuable off-street parking. With its attractive design, versatile configuration, established occupancy, and convenient location, this property presents a unique opportunity to add a distinctive Rochester office asset to your portfolio.

263 Central Ave Avenue, Rochester

$415,000

R1609155 MLS

Positioned in the heart of Rochester’s dynamic South Wedge neighborhood, 161 Comfort Street offers ±3,330 square feet of highly functional warehouse/flex space just off South Clinton Avenue. With immediate access to I-490 and Downtown Rochester, this property combines convenience, flexibility, and location in one compelling package. The building is approximately 90% open warehouse/flex space with 10% finished office space at the front, including two full bathrooms. The space offers 12-foot ceilings with 14-foot clear height to the joist—ideal for a variety of light industrial, production, storage, or creative uses. The property has a 200AMP electrical service with potential upgrades available on site. The building has a convenient private parking lot in the rear allowing -/+ 10 spaces accessible from the side alleyway for staff and clients. Recent updates and features include: A new A/C mini-split system (2024) servicing the front office, upgraded lighting throughout the building (2019), and a local security system. The property is also well-positioned for further functionality—with a grade-level door that can be easily installed at the rear, opening up additional options for shipping, deliveries, or accommodating a variety of small flex and retail uses. Whether you’re an owner-user, or investor looking to establish a footprint in one of Rochester’s most active neighborhoods, 161 Comfort Street offers versatility and convenience in one prime location. The property can be considered for lease to an established tenant.

161 Comfort Street, Rochester

Start Your Search

Between $400K - $500K Rochester Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for between $400k - $500k properties available in Rochester and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!